![]() |
Sustainable
Development Network Ltd
....Your RESOURCE CENTRE.... |
CASE STUDIES
Below are some case studies of what others are doing that we have collected from various sources.
Click any heading below to read about a case study of your choice.
|
New!!! Sawdust To The Rescue 'Entrepreneurship Is Like Giving Birth To A Baby, Nurturing It...' Strengthed Societies: Lessons From Other Nations Greenhouse Farming, Wealth At Your Backyard
|
|
Sawdust To
The Rescue
BY GODWIN IJEDIOGOR The Guardian November 6, 2004
Honour came calling recently for Godson Echegile when he won a
merit award for outstanding contribution to the development and
utilisation of Nigeria's raw materials. In addition to being export
material, his briquettes, which are made from sawdust, supply an
option for industrial and domestic heating locally.
ECHEGILE can hardly contain his enthusiasm. He says,
"briquette is a readily available replacement for firewood for
home cooking, especially in the northern part of the country where
there is serious desert encroachment problem as a result of
deforestation. It is used in the southern part of the country also,
including Lagos, but especially by the bakers for the heating of
their ovens. It is much cheaper than firewood or gas and in terms of
heat value, it is also higher than even the hardest of firewood you
can find around in the country. It is also cheaper to manage than
other sources of heating energy." "We were exporting the product previously but since the
suspension of the 40 per cent Export Grant, we have reduced the
quantity we now export and are trying to see if we can develop the
local market. That 40 per cent grant was quite substantial in our
cash flow. So if you remove it, we cannot break even in the export
trade," he says.
At the moment, Echegile's is the only such industry in the
country. Over 99 per cent of its products were formerly exported to
Europe, particularly Netherlands. "We were competing with such
products from South Africa, Ghana and some parts of Asia.
"It could still be lucrative if the company could push up
the price internationally, but that is quite difficult, because we
contribute less than one per cent of the total international market
of the product. Indeed, any attempt at that would mean pricing
ourselves out of a market, over which we do not have control and
where there are other suppliers." Says Echegile, "Before now, we were buying dry saw dust at
N2.20 per kilogramme. But because of increase in the prices of
petroleum products, and the attendant rise in the cost of
transportation, it has gone up to N3.50 per kilogramme today. But
the raw material is readily available and we have no problem with
supplies." "On one of our visits to Taiwan in 1997, we found out that
sawdust could be converted to an alternative energy source, called
briquette, which they were exporting. And since we had a technical
relationship with them, we pleaded and they gave us the necessary
technology for briquette production. Since then, we have been in the
business of converting sawdust into briquettes for export and
domestic and industrial heating.
He insists that briquettes are much cheaper and easier to use
them kerosene or even cooking gas. "A pack of 10kg briquettes
which sells for a token of N300 can be used by a family of four for
one month." Echegile has only one regret; that genuine exporters like him are
now suffering as a result of the alleged sharp practices in the
allocation of the grant. He says, "The frequent policy changes
is not good for planning. For instance, last year we ordered for
bigger machines, hoping to increase our export market and went ahead
to enter into some contracts along that line.
"But today, we cannot export. The machines arrived not quite
long ago and have been lying idle in our premises. We refused to
install them because we cannot export any longer. So if policies are
made, I think there should be a fixed time for the policy to mature
and take root, rather than terminating or suspending such policies
midway, after genuine investors must have borrowed money to expand,
with the hope that the policies would be allowed to mature." But there is hope. "The moment we solve the problem of power
supply, because these new machines are from Europe and much more
rugged, unlike the former one from China which was prone to
occasional break downs, we will be able to upgrade our production
capacity, now that we know that the market is there." The company participated in the 7th RMRDC Techno-Expo 2004 held
in Abuja between October 12 and 15 and organised by the Raw
Materials Research and Development Council (RMRDC) of the Federal
Ministry of Science and Technology, at the end of which it won a
merit award for outstanding contribution to the development and
utilisation of Nigeria's raw materials.
Briquettes are suitable for domestic/household cooking,
combustion of boilers, bakeries, iron and steel pot making. It is
made from sawdust without additives, does not spark-when burning and
burns with very low smoke emission.
It lights quickly with minimum ash content and leaves no dirt
like charcoal. Briquette, unlike charcoal and dry wood, has between
4,500 and 6,000 calorie per gram (col/g), with moisture content of
six per cent.
Celina Industries, according to Echegile, produces two grades of
briquette - carbonised and uncarbonised. The former is lighter and
has almost reduced impurities like ash, with increased carbon
content. Briquette, since made from hardwood, is also known to repel
mosquitoes.
The factory presently produces between 400 and 500 metric tonnes
of briquettes per month. Ota is a vantage site for the industry
because the town hosts the three biggest wood factories in the
country.
It is packaged in a 10kg pack, and while the uncarbonised goes
for N300, the carbonised cost N10, 000. At the moment, it has three
major distributors in the country. The products go as far as
Maiduguri, Kano and Aba, with some of the finding their way into
Chad Republic.
To set up such an industry, Echegile says all your need is the
necessary capital, which he puts at "between $800,000 and $1
million today for the part and equipment and the bank support at a
very good interest rate, rent or buy a warehouse and source the raw
material.
Certainly, you cannot run such a factory on 30 or 35 per cent
interest rate loan.
While not condemning the ritual of tree planting every year,
Echegile says "you can plant trees but if people do not have
alternatives to firewood, especially where they cannot afford
kerosene, all will be waste, because the rural poor must cook for
their families." "Ten packs of briquette, which is 70kg will back up to 10
bags of flour. So they now have a standard energy requirement and do
not need to be at the bakery everyday.
"All such a baker needs to do is to issue 10 packs of
briquettes for 10 bags of flour and leaves." "The dry saw dust is processed through the hopper to the
fast drier, down to the machine where the extrusion takes place.
If it is wet, the heat cannot extract the wax; instead it will
extract water, which is not a binding agent." 'Entrepreneurship Is Like Giving Birth To A Baby, Nurturing It...' The Guardian (Online version) 04-09-2004 EVEN though she thought of making a soap that would be tender on young people's hands due to her unpleasant experience with soda soap as a youth, Mrs. Maria Eka had always wanted to be a corporate person. Setting up a small-scale industry was not on the cards. But having worked in the Federal Civil Service between 1971 and 1985 where she rose to the position of Assistant Director, and later the banking industry from where she quit paid employment in 1995, Mrs. Eka finally settled for her one-time dream by chance. An advertisement in the newspaper was all that was needed to take her back to it. And today, the Managing Director of Mainspring Ventures, a Lagos-based outfit that produces Spring soap, after undergoing a training at the Federal Institute of Industrial Research, Oshodi (FIIRO), Lagos is awaiting the approval/certification of the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC) to enable her go full throttle after a period of successful test-run and market-sampling.She spoke with GODWIN IJEDIOGOR. "I DID not originally think I wanted to start a business. I attended Queen's College, Lagos and the kind of training they gave us was not commercial-oriented, but to become refined and educated women generally. When I finished from the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria where I studied Sociology, my dream was to join the Foreign Service. "But my uncle refused because he felt that I may not get married early if I did. He wanted me to get married after working for a while. That was the thinking in those days. So I took up a job in the Federal Civil Service. I always wanted to be a corporate person, not to start a business. "When I left the civil service, I joined a bank - Centre Point Merchant Bank, now defunct, but on leaving the bank in 1995, I suddenly one day saw an advertisement in a newspaper that FIIRO was training people to make soap and other things. I thought it might be a good idea to do something for people to clean with. I remember when I was a little girl that we used to wash with a local soap called soda in my house. It used to bruise my hands and so my father exempted me from washing with it. "I always thought of making a better soap that will be gentle on the hands of little girls one day. So when I read the advertisement, I felt that it was an opportunity to learn soap-making and to realise this my dream." So she went for the training at FIIRO and on finishing, wanted to try her hands on the business almost immediately, no matter at what scale. She later set up a small factory which has now grown to a point of seeking NAFDAC's registration.She was initially afraid of putting all her money into the business even though it was dear to her and she wanted it to succeed. And although what she had was not enough to see her dream realised, she didn't want to borrow for her to expand the business. "So what I did was to start very small. First in my guard's room because at that time we were not having a mai-guard. I just moved a few equipment into the place and started. Later, I took over our boys quarters when the guard's room became small for the business." At another point in the transition and growth of the business, that too became choked up. So she once again moved the office/factory into the second flat (behind the bigger house) in their Ogudu, Lagos residence.She soon overgrew that too and now that she is in the process of getting registered by NAFDAC, she had to relocate once more to the government -owned Technology Business Incubation Centre (TBIC) in Agege area of Lagos. The alternative was to change some things in the house, including design, to suit that purpose. But she chose it for convenience, especially as the neighbours had started grumbling. Moreso, her husband, being an environmentalist, advised that she relocate to the estate. "At the beginning, I was doing the whole thing by myself," she said, churning out one or two cartons per day. And the patronage was weaved around her friends and some neighbours who commended her efforts and product. "A few of my relations even use it to bath," she enthused. Right now, Spring soap can be found in some local government areas in Lagos State, pending when she obtains certification/approval from NAFDAC. Thereafter, Mrs. Eka hopes to spread to other parts of the state and the country, and even into the West African sub-region. For according to her, "a few people from outside the country have seen and used it and they like it." Her initial challenges may not be different from those of other entrepreneurs. "We had problems of good workers. Some would come today and go away suddenly and you had to start looking for new hands.The initial equipment that were locally fabricated for us, some didn't work and we went through some troubles. The machine was not cutting properly and sometimes, over 30 per cent came out as off- cuts. So we had the problem of trying to fabricate new ones or repair the defective ones. "There was lack of necessary infrastructure too. Power supply was so erratic and unreliable at the time we started that we couldn't put some of the big equipment to use. We had to do some things manually. It was like you put soap in a mixer and suddenly power goes and you put on the stand-by generator and a problem occurs. By the time you fix this in a couple of minutes, the whole thing would have caked and you lose so much money. "Another recurring problem was constant police harassment on the road for no good reason. Sometimes, out distribution vehicles also get stopped by local government revenue officials and the drivers harassed. You go into one local government and you pay. The moment you go into another, they expect you to also pay, and you keep paying depending on the number of local governments that you traverse," she bemoaned. Overcoming these challenges, she explained, has been by the grace of God. She has also held on to her dream. "I have been very determined. It's like doing something that I had always wanted to do. It's like giving birth to a baby, nurturing it, no matter the odds. I initially tried to get on with my own finance, but after some time I got some support from my husband. Right now, I am also using a loan facility from my bank." Sourcing the equipment and raw materials, she said,did not pose any headache. She got introduced to a local machine fabricator while undergoing training at FIIRO and bought from others outside. The main input, palm kernel oil, is also sourced locally from two or three companies around for some years now. "Palm kernel oil is seasonal and unsteady. It gets scarce and expensive during the dry season. At the beginning of last year it sold for about N100, 000 per ton, but rose to about N160, 000 per ton later in the year. But the prices are a bit stable this year and it has not been as difficult sourcing for the materials as last year." She believes this is because more people appear to be growing palm trees in Nigeria now than before. Mrs. Eka started with about N250, 000 in 1995, which she considers small compared to the over N2.5m it will require to start on the same scale today. Her pre-occupation now is geared toward obtaining NAFDAC certification and registration. Her vision from thence would be "that the company will grow to become a multinational, producing soap and other things. A company run efficiently; profitable and employing so many Nigerians." As a mother of five adults, the last of whom is an undergraduate, Mrs. Eka has not found it difficult running the home and office together. Indeed, she has only the 'big baby,' her husband, to care for on full-time basis. But she admitted that it could be very hectic at times, especially as she does all her cooking herself. She counselled: "I believe that a woman should give a great amount of her time to her home; put as much as she is putting in her business into running her home.When everything is right in the home, then you will be able to do your business without any problems." Even at that, she acknowledged that it would have been more hectic for her had the children been younger. She recalled: "When the children were younger and I was working in the banking sector and the civil service, it was obviously more hectic and tedious." She was, however lucky to have had her mother-in-law around to relieve her of some of the home duties and caring for the children.Again, she admitted that sometimes, the 'big baby' complains. To her, "it's expected and I try to explain and go round it by being extra nice to him." For those entrepreneurs whose children are much younger, she advised: "Get a lot of help in running the home and try to spend whatever extra time you have with the children. And if you can, work near home when you are younger." As for mentors or role models, none readily came to her mind although there are a lot of successful women that she admires. "I try to see how they have coped. I read motivational books a lot, to see how the great entrepreneurs and millionaires made it." She cannot place her hand on one person in particular with regards to her area of business. Given another opportunity, would she take to manufacturing (entrepreneurship) against paid employment After a short meditation and flashback, she answered: "Hmm,
when I was younger, I thought the corporate world was better. In
fact, I loved the corporate world so much and before I started
manufacturing, I thought it was better. But now, I think I prefer
the manufacturing world. The challenges are more and it's like you
nurturing something to fruition. It's a thing of joy."
All the same, penetrating the already saturated market has not been
easy. Indeed, at a point when the sales started dwindling, she had
to be involved, doing it herself.Hear her experience: "At the
beginning, I had a few staff doing the sales. I remember there was a
lot of glut that year with so many indigenous soaps in the market
and each time they went out, they returned to tell me dismal
stories. I didn't want to dirty my clothes, so to speak, in going
about selling my products initially, maybe because of my civil
service and banking orientation. But as the sales dwindled, one day
I just said to myself, 'why don't you go and do it yourself
"So I just put my suit aside and tied my Iro and Buba and went
around with them, waded through the poto-poto (muddy water) in the
markets. I went round to talk to the women traders and believe me,
things started to change. We started getting more customers. I did
that for some time until we stabilised.
"I found out that going personally to the customers helped me
to make sales over 10 times more than I was making before when I was
faceless and nobody knew the manufacturer of the soap.Right now, I
know almost every customer in the market who patronises my company
personally and speak with them from time to time, even though my
staff go to them almost on daily basis. And that has helped a
lot."
Expectedly, some people could not imagine her doing it herself, and
they voiced out such reservations. "A few people, especially
friends said , 'how can you do that kind of thing, having worked in
the civil service and bank'
But it never bothered her, so long as the necessary sales were made
and her project kept going.
Speaking from experience, she said: "If you run a business, you sometimes need to know some of your customers. Do some of the sales yourself; join the production people from time to time and know exactly what is going on in your company. It is good for small businesses like ours." In employing some staff, especially young school leavers, she has had to train some of them on the nitty-gritty of soap making, free of charge.
She said although she never had cause to look back, some moments
were dull enough to make a weakling want to turn back.But her
husband was always handy, urging her on at such moments. One
particular experience concerned one of her former sales boys.
"The head of a church introduced him to me and I felt he was
good and genuine, coming from a man of God. I think I was a bit
careless; I didn't take all the necessary references I should have
taken if he was coming from another source.
"After a few months, he made away with a lot of my money and I
was very upset. It took me some time to get out of it. It was a
nasty experience and it drew me back."
To her, the government is doing something to encourage small
businesses, though it may not be enough. "Government is trying
to do some things, but I think there is still a lot to be done,
especially in the area of infrastructure provision. Take electricity
for example. Because NEPA is not working optimally, it is difficult
for a company that cannot afford a generating set. The money spent
on power supply could have been spent in other areas to make such a
company grow.
"In Lagos, every other house is a shop and they are building
more shopping centres. I cannot see any new industrial estates
springing up. So the government needs to do more about finding
accommodation for small businesses. Even the existing estates do not
have efficient and functional infrastructure."
Her tips to a would-be entrepreneur in her own field: "Be very
focused and determined. Start small and grow big. Don't rush things.
I started small; I am still small and believe in playing small and
focused. Your establishment should stay the size you can manage
properly and efficiently."
Click here to go back to the top
Strengthed Societies: Lessons From Other Nations From The Guardian (Online Edition) Sunday July 18, 2004 In India, Punjab government is fully stressing to promote the cooperative movement. Many steps have been taken in this direction. For example, in wheat procurement, cooperative societies are made shareholders. It means they were introduced as a provisional commission agents. This scheme was introduced at local points those were ?near to cities. Seeds and fertilizers are also provided to farmers near villages. To give loans to farmers at a lower rate, Rs.113 crores have been allotted for this scheme. So they can be saved from money-lenders. Godowns are provided to farmers to keep their surplus food items by the cooperative societies. Many godowns have been raising for this purpose. Primary Cooperative Societies are giving fertilizers, seeds, pesticides to farmers as loans to farmers. 2900 agriculture sources are working in the State under 15 Central Cooperative Societies. Cooperative Bank have given Rs.200.49 crores as loans to farmers. The Cyprus Agricultural Cooperatives movement was established in Cyprus during the period of British rule to better the economic conditions of farmers and villagers. As of 1987, there were 257 active cooperative societies in the "TRNC." Most villages and towns had cooperative credit unions that provided savings and loan services for members. Loans were made both in cash and in kind (items needed for farming) to assist cooperative society members. One of the banks operating in the "TRNC" was the cooperative societies' own bank, the Turkish Cypriot Cooperative Central Bank. The government oversaw the activities of the societies through the Office of the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. In East Africa, smallholder farmers produce most of the agricultural output, but lack adequate knowledge and experience to operate on an even footing in the marketplace. By virtue of their small landholdings, most farmers are unable to decrease costs, increase efficiencies, reduce risks and aggregate product for cost-effective sales. Given the dismal history of cooperative efforts in East Africa, newly emerging farmers' organizations require extensive training and technical assistance in all facets of business association management and market access. The Kenya Farmer-to-Farmer Program is a component of ACDI/VOCA's Worldwide Farmer-to Farmer (WWFTF), Greater Horn of Africa program. The major goal of the Worldwide Farmer-to-Farmer program in the Greater Horn of Africa is to enhance food security and market-access opportunities by working with farmer-based cooperatives and smallholder associations at the grass-roots level, strengthening the capacity of institutions working for agricultural development and utilizing local capacity and technology to improve agricultural production for local and export markets. As an entity with staff and status independent of the Uganda and Rwanda programs, the Farmer-to-Farmer (FtF) program has been operating in Kenya since October, 2001. The project seeks to encourage the economic and social development of the agriculture sector with the ultimate desire that farmers will get more profit for their products through an approach that addresses the needs of individuals in the rural areas, and contributes to national economic growth through the development of the private sector by supporting agribusiness, cooperatives and NGO's working to increase profits and assist agricultural development. This directly contributes to USAID's Strategic Objective No. 7 (SO7): Increasing Rural Household Incomes, as well as ACDI/VOCA's goal of ensuring increased viability of the agricultural sector by strengthening targeted sub-sectors within the agribusiness community. To achieve these objectives, an integrated approach to enhance quality of products, management, marketing, market information access and transportation networks to increase produce movement from surplus to demand areas, as well as development of other support activities such as extension services, is required. The Kenya FtF program is currently establishing its relationships with producer, marketing and processor entities as well as government agencies and other development organizations, which have a stake in some of these industries. The achievement of these goals has been focused on the improvement of the operations of smallholder associations that currently lack adequate representation resulting from the near collapse of the cooperative movement in Kenya. Initial FtF volunteer assignments in Kenya have focused largely on the development of associations' abilities to effectively serve their members. A text written by the Federation of Danish Cooperatives in collaboration with the Agricultural Council, elaborates how the commercial enterprises owned by the Danish farmers and organized as cooperatives. According to the report, today, agriculture is the most important trade sector in Denmark. "Two thirds of the production is exported, 30 percent of the total Danish export is agricultural products, and agriculture is important for employment in Denmark". "A major reason for the strength and success of Danish agriculture is the collaboration of the farmers. The individual farmers face a string of challenges, not only in their daily production, but also in the surrounding world: the market, the technological development, political conditions for production and sales". And so, in Denmark, the farmers have organized themselves in various ways to solve the problems, which many farmers have in common. . "The farmers have economic interests in the market and have established cooperatives". Click here to go back to the top RAYFIELD area in Jos metropolis is famed for a number of things, but probably not for this one: greenhouse farming. But it exists there, unsung. Behind this project is a woman who has chosen not to be daunted by adverse experiences in whatever she does. Mrs. Julie Makama is a greenhouse farmer, and an experienced one at that. Circumstances and experiences in vegetable production led her into considering greenhouse farming. Hear her story: "I came about greenhouse farming (as) I was involved in planting vegetables like any other person. I found out that everybody was growing the same thing at the same time". This has many implications for the commodities. "Most vegetables can't stand a lot of rains. Most people wait for the end of the rains to plant. At harvest, so much vegetables (especially tomatoes) are in the market, and the price falls", she narrated. Bitter experience followed the market trend she tried to explain here: "At a time, I got about 100 baskets and sold at N50 per bag as against N1,000 during the rains. I (later) discovered that growing tomatoes under glass shields them from rains and they do well. So I embarked on greenhouse farming to be able to produce tomatoes during the rainy season at a good price because they fetch more money during the rainy season, whereas there is glut during the dry season and they are underpriced". Mrs. Makama considered that greenhouse farming is so beneficial and that "you cannot quantify the benefits, if you can go out of your way to construct one". Although it is "capital intensive", she was of the opinion that materials for construction can still be improvised. According to her, a friend constructed one, using transparent polythene covering and spent just N10,000. On her own, too, Mrs. Makama started in a small way. "I started with one makeshift (costing N100,000 then). It was about 30 metres long (but was not sure of the exact breadth), made of wood and polythene. It was used for about five years. I later had a delivery of a fabricated version from Israel". To Mrs. Makama, all was not profit at first. "At first, I had losses with the makeshift due to inexperience because I went in at first as a hobby". She later saw it as a means of livelihood. At that time, "despite the initial losses, I kept persevering". With tomatoes in particular, she was having problems of nematodes and wilting, which she later overcame. "A Danish expert came and offered to help me out. He turned the farm around (within months). They place (from) where we were not getting up to N50,000, we were getting close to N300,000. Later, I terminated the partnership. My brother on the farm learnt a lot from the farm", she explained. "You don't get rich through growing vegetables", she said a friend told her. Her answer, however, was simple: "Not these days." Gains are now pouring in. "This year, I had realised N400,000. If not for windstorm that brought down the entire greenhouse earlier this year, we would have been talking of the second harvest", by now. She is methodical in her greenhouse farming approach. She told The Guardian that she has recorded "about 90 percent success, using polythene bags filled with soil to grow tomatoes as a way of overcoming the tomato diseases and nematode infections". She was excited in narrating her story: It is "time consuming and capital intensive. I am learning from my mistakes and I am getting better and better." She observed that "greenhouse farming is not very common and not very popular" in Nigeria now. One of the reasons, she noted, was that "some of those doing it would not want to make it known to others so as to continue to take advantage of it. But I believe it is good to share it with our farmers group". On Mrs. Makama's greenhouse farm, tomatoes as sold in kilogrammes not in bags or baskets. She also grows broccoli, which she said she had introduced to the villagers. Apart from the edibles, Mrs. Makama grows cut flowers in the greenhouse. For instance she grows roses, and she makes fortune from it. "I have been supplying NICON Hotel for the past 10 years", she disclosed. "It is these roses that have been sustaining the farm".
Watch out for more case studies here |
We are grateful to Kabissa for making the hosting of this website possible